Friday, July 11, 2008

Modern-Day Heretics: Bill Donohue

Editor's Note: This is the first post in a series I'm starting, where I find people who claim to be Christian acting in extremely un-Christian ways and, rather than resort to the usual namby-pamby language used by Christians on the left side of the spectrum, actually call them out for heresy.

I'm actually a bit surprised I haven't written about Bill Donohue, president of the ultra-right-wing Catholic League, in the past. It's not like he hasn't taken every opportunity available to act like a horse's ass and offend - well, really, anyone who isn't also a right-wing Catholic.

But if he wasn't guilty of the deep heresy and sacrilege of misrepresenting Christ before, he most certainly is now. Here's the story:

Recently, a student at the University of Central Florida - a public school - removed the Eucharist from the campus Roman Catholic church instead of eating it as he was supposed to. Now, I know what the Eucharist means to Catholics, and I understand why the church would get a bit upset about this, but at this point it's a local issue - church calls up kid, kid says "okay," returns Eucharist, problem solved. Right?

But wait - here's Bill Donohue! He wouldn't let any opportunity pass to make some (mostly) innocent kid's life a living hell! He and his "Catholic" League (real Catholicism, while problematically sexist and homophobic, still shouldn't be characterized by Donohue's asshattishness) decided that this kid hadn't been punished enough and made a big case out of it.
“We don’t know 100% what Mr. Cooks motivation was,” said Susan Fani a spokesperson with the local Catholic diocese. “However, if anything were to qualify as a hate crime, to us this seems like this might be it.”
A hate crime? I mean, I know you're all trying to play the victim here because that's what you pathetic people do, but a frakkin' hate crime?

The kid is receiving death threats now! Bill Donohue's "Christians" are trying to get him kicked out of school (and Fox News, true to asshat-enabling form, tells people in the article exactly how to file a complaint against this kid, no matter whether they have any connection to UCF or not) for taking a wafer out of church. Seriously, I know Roman Catholics believe that it's the actual body, but I think the "Catholic" League has forgotten exactly whose body it is - the body of a man who preached forgiveness, reconciliation, and love, not vengefulness, bitterness, and hate.

So that's it, right? Wrong. A University of Minnesota professor named PZ Myers blogged about this - very irreverently and offensively, I'll admit - on his personal website, as is his right as a human being with the right to free speech. Bill Donohue, who can't let an opportunity pass to (a) make another person's life a living hell, and (b) convince even more people that he's a flaming asshole who has no earthly clue who Jesus Christ actually is, decided that he has to go, too.

Now Prof. Myers is receiving death threats and hate mail as well - most of which are, typical of the kind of mouth-breathing Neanderthals who send death threats to people for writing on the Internet, characterized by poor spelling, grammar, and no evidence of rational thought - and, what's worse, his university president is receiving demands that he be fired. For posting on his personal website.

So I'm going to do two things here:

A. I'm going to ask my readership - all three of you - to please send an email to UMN president Robert Bruininks supporting Prof. Myers's right to free speech (even if you disagree with what he said, which I do, at least with the offensive part in question). Please be respectful, use your full name, and do all those spelling and grammar things that death-threat-sending Neanderthals haven't quite mastered yet.

B. I'm going to call out Donohue and his merry band of haters for what they are - heretics and blasphemers. If it is heresy and blasphemy to add an iota to a single word in a creed, then surely it is heresy and blasphemy to represent the Christ of love and reconciliation with words and actions of hate and vengefulness. It's time to be bold and say that Bill Donohue and the "Catholic" League are, in fact, acting against Christ, and need to repent of their hatefulness.

Okay... Seminary hat off now.

Labels: , , ,

Comments:
What's fair is fair...
NEW YORK (AP) _ A 23-year-old man was arrested Friday on hate-crime charges after he threw a Quran in a toilet at Pace University on two separate occasions, police said.

Stanislav Shmulevich of Brooklyn was arrested on charges of criminal mischief and aggravated harassment, both hate crimes, police said. It was unclear if he was a student at the school. A message left at the Shmulevich home was not immediately returned.

The Islamic holy book was found in a toilet at Pace's lower Manhattan campus by a teacher on Oct. 13. A student discovered another book in a toilet on Nov. 21, police said.

Muslim activists had called on Pace University to crack down on hate crimes after the incidents. As a result, the university said it would offer sensitivity training to its students.

The school was accused by Muslim students of not taking the incident seriously enough at first. Pace classified the first desecration of the holy book as an act of vandalism, but university officials later reversed themselves and referred the incident to the New York Police Department's hate crimes unit.
 
jimg
And this excuses death threats how, exactly?
 
This post has been removed by a blog administrator.
 
Don't know...ask Salmon Rushdie. Not saying this guy is not a kook, but kooks live on both sides and you seem to be looking to the right only...the "Christian" right specifically, to define it under the terms of the kookiest you can find. What if we define the left in terms of Harry Bellefonte, George Soros or Dennis Kucinich (I'm at work right now and given time, I could come up with a few better ones than these.
 
@jimg

Do the people threatening Salman Rushdie do it in the name of Christ? Are they claiming the mantle of Christianity as they force him to run for his life?

Because that's the main problem I have with Donohue and his merry band of haters - not that they're engaging in a campaign of terror against those whose views they don't like, which is bad enough in and of itself, but that they're doing that in the name of Christ. At the same time as they engage in acts of hate and vengefulness, at the same time as they speak words of violence toward another human being, at the same time as they try to destroy someone's livelihood simply because they disagree with him, they also claim that these actions are done for Christ.

I can't speak to the Islamic tradition, threatening as the radical fundamentalist element in that religion may be. I don't know enough about Islam, and I'm an outsider to that religion.

I can, by virtue of my theological education and my being a Christian, speak to the Christian tradition. And it's time for us in the Church to do some house cleaning - to drive the hate out of our Temple, the Body of Christ, to call hatred for others out for the heresy it is.
 
Good points, Jim. How about the Reverend Wright, then?
 
Please direct me, if you will, to the incidents in which Rev. Wright tried to get someone fired, or incited his followers to issue things like death threats, to people who disagreed with him.

Also please direct me to anything Rev. Wright said that is functionally different from things said by the Hebrew Prophets. He was a bit strong, and had some facts mixed up, but many of his controversial proclamations could have been ripped straight out of Amos or Jeremiah.
 
Post a Comment





<< Home

Blogroll

Big Orange
The "Blog"
Bleed Cubbie Blue
Oratorical Animal
Blogora: RSA Blog
Huffington Post
The Nation

Previous Posts

A nation of whiners?
John McCain channels Steve Martin
To funny not to be true
So let me get this straight...
McCain's adviser crosses waaaay over the line
Add this to your list of "things that are awesome"...
Switch Hitter vs. Switch Pitcher
Forward this to all your friends.
BREAKING NEWS
That Obama guy's pretty popular.

Archives

March 2008   April 2008   May 2008   June 2008   July 2008   August 2008  

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Subscribe to Posts [Atom]